Star Wars Animation and Live Action Series: I'm Not a Fan of Dave Filoni But I'm Coming Around

The Clone Wars, Season 7, Episode 9,
Old Friends Not Forgotten.

From the outside looking in Dave Filoni seems to be the keeper of the Star Wars Universe, outside of the feature films - though his influence is definitely heading that way as well.

If you're not aware Filoni has been mostly the creative vision, and driving force behind Star Wars animation since he co-developed The Clone Wars Animated series with George Lucas, long before Disney bought the Star Wars franchise.

Other animated Star Wars series he's been key to include; The Bad Batch, Star Wars: Rebels, Star Wars: Resistance, and Star Wars: Forces of Destiny.

Ever since he was invited to help develop Jon Favreau's live action Star Wars series, The Mandalorian, and The Book of Boba Fett, characters from Filoni's animated shows have been crossing into live action. So much so that Filoni has written and directed entire episodes featuring his animated cross-over characters. The entire third season of The Mandalorian could have been called 'The Book of Bo-Katan Kryze' - a Mandalorian character played by Katee Sackhoff in both animation and live action.

It is because Filioni has had so much input into the live action shows - noting that the upcoming (as I write this) live action series, Ahsoka, is being viewed as a continuation of Star Wars: Rebels - that I decided to go back and watch all of the animated shows.

While I had previously watched all of The Clone Wars up to season five, that was pretty much where I parted ways with Star Wars animation. I didn't like the show as much as I would've hoped because it was set between the second and third prequel films - still two of my most least liked films of the Star Wars Saga.

This time I didn't go back and watch each series in chronological order. I decided to give The Bad Batch another go after initially watching the first episode when released and not really getting into it. I then watched the last two seasons of The Clone Wars (Season 7 is the best of all of these shows and I'd strongly suggest watching that before The Bad Batch - which is a spin off from Season 7). Next I went to Rebels, and finally Resistance.

Note that I had already watched all of Forces of Destiny but that show is more of a fun aside than essential viewing since the episodes are so short.

Dave Filoni - 2010
Image: Wikipedia.org

Watching all of Filoni's animated shows, he definitely has a formula of four or five archetype characters he throws together. Usually the smart one, the wise experienced hero, the goof ball, the muscle, and a droid (because it's Star Wars). Sometimes he mixes up the combinations but you can see them if you squint.

The shows themselves are often difficult to get into at the start because the characters are new. They tend to potter around in their corner of the universe, as we get to know them, before they start to bump into bigger themes and characters of the Star Wars universe overall. That's usually when the shows become interesting.

I was most reminded of this most, watching Star Wars: Resistance, which had to overcome a new animation style from the previous series, as well as a time jump into the rise of The First Order period (which I liked once that became more part of the story, because the main character really is the 'Mr Bean' of spies and is just awful).

My viewing of the Filoni-verse (as it is often referred to) was helped greatly by watching it projected large on a wall using a mini digital projector. Somehow watching cartoons on a big screen is way more engaging than regular TV or a mobile device.

Overall, I wouldn't call myself a fan of Dave Filoni's Star Wars. I particularly don't like that his animated shows have kind of hijacked the live action shows. After seeing Andor, while I was frustrated that so many episodes early on seemed to drag, that series matured into a story that was really worth going through the frustration. I'd like more of that. Filoni's Star Wars kind of pales by comparison.

That said, Filoni's Star Wars isn't bad by any means. I'm definitely coming around. I just hope he doesn't become the only game in town and we continue to get other creative voices adding their vision into the Star Wars universe too. Filoni is great for the more mainstream, action based, stories that keeps a majority of fans engaged. However, every once in a while, we need an Andor to remind us there's more to Star Wars than light sabers and space battles.

Comments

I'm Confused About Why People Prefer to Say Discombobulated?

D iscombobulated. Is a word that I think someone rediscovered about three or four years ago (maybe more because the pandemic years have thrown out my sense of time) and now I hear it a lot. It's not a new word by any means, but when I started hearing multiple celebrities using it in everyday sentences, I actively had to look up what it meant. Define it with as many synonyms as you like but essentially it's just another word meaning 'confused'. Seinfeld Quotes: Quotes.net The words are pretty much interchangeable. He was discombobulated by too many choices. He was confused by too many choices. My confusion is the length of the word. It's unnecessarily long with too many syllables. There are many other words that mean confused, and therefore also mean discombobulated. Most of them are shorter and easier to say. So why not just say 'confused'? Perhaps discombobulated sounds more intelligent, maybe? Hawaii Five-0 Quotes: Quotes.net I've noticed it gets us...

Introducing the Second Sunday Skateboard Sessions - Doing Less to Skateboard More

This was my second heelflip attempt of the day. I was pleased I at least got the full rotation even if I didn't land it. I am determined to keep skating for as long as possible, though, since my last post in May 2024, about reigniting my kickflip battle at age 54 , I've probably been skateboarding less than I had hoped. Still haven't landed that elusive kickflip either. Strangely I've been wanting to film myself skateboarding again but have been reluctant to do so because it can be a bit of a hassle trying to create interesting content, not to mention a lot of editing, if you want to capture the full journey of learning a trick. I really hate editing. Looking at my camera equipment the other day I was thinking what is the most minimal setup that I can put together that would make it easy to film skate videos anywhere? I landed on using my Samsung A13, Android phone, mounted on a GoPro selfie stick that has a tripod base in the handle, and a wireless mic I bought some t...

TV Series Review: Skeleton Crew (2024) (Disney+) No Spoilers

I f you saw the trailer for Skeleton Crew and decided the show looked too much like Star Wars for little kids, and didn't watch, you missed out on a real treat. While I will say this show was definitely targeted at bringing in younger fans to the Star Wars universe, it is very much more like family viewing than kids only TV. Not to mention, characters are literally gunned down or murdered on this show, but without the really graphic violence you might see on a more adult orientated show. It's actually no more kid only orientated than the first series of Stranger Things (2016), or even the original Star Wars (1977) movie. In fact the whole show is a not so subtle homage to original Star Wars (1977), Treasure Island (1950), and eighties movies like The Goonies (1985), ET (1982), Explorers (1985) and others. The plot is very straight forward. A group of children, living in the Star Wars equivalent of the suburbs, find an aband...

The Princess' Butterflies - Using an AI Image to Video Generator to Animate Art That Started as a 23 Year Old Rough Pen Sketch

B ack in October of 2023 I used Prome AI's Sketch Rendering feature to color a 23 year old rough pen sketch I did of a princess watching butterflies, sitting next to a waterfall in the forest. You can read more about that in my previous article, The Princess' Butterflies - Using an AI Art Generator to Color and Enhance a 23 Year Old Rough Pen Sketch The three images I used to create my final image (bottom right). Notice how closely the AI has followed my line art sketch (top left) but in the first image (top right) has misinterpreted the waterfall as some kind of large tree stump. Prome's render of the artwork was pretty good but I did end up creating a composite image myself from two of the best renders, to get my final image. Since then AI Image to Video has come a long way, particularly when it comes to creating animation from artwork and maintaining the art style for the whole generation. AI still does much better with turning photographic images to video but I found ...

Two Former Right Wing Australian PM's Call Out President Trump and His America First Approach

Q uite often, leaders on all sides of politics, once they've retired from office, become the kind of person, with a political view that I would've supported, if they had been that person with that viewpoint, when they were leaders. Case in point, two former right wing, Australian Prime Ministers were individually interviewed about President Trump's negative impact on Australia and global politics in general. Both said things that even a left leaning 'woke' voter like myself could get behind and nod in agreement with. Keep in mind both these former PM's are right wing politicians that should be aligned with the US Republican party, and President Trump's views on many issues. Malcolm Turnbull Mr Turnbull, like President Trump is a businessman turned politician. He's a person I was all set to vote for until he aligned himself with the Australian Liberal Party. Which was a little unexpected for me because up to that point his politics sounded more left than ...

Meanwhile, In Australia... The World's Most Boring Government Is Fine... We're All Fine.

That's um... What's his name? T o be honest, I stopped following politics in Australia years ago. The only time I check in is usually around election time just to see which set of woke lefty independents, I'm going to vote for, ahead of my fallbacks of the Greens, and then Labor. Despite my sister trying to categorise me as more of a 'left brained' person I definitely lean 'right brained' more at home with my cry baby, woke, alphabet, lefty people. (For the record, if this is the first musing of mine you've ever read, I'm a straight white male who identifies as an artist... Male artist - just in case you were thinking artist is some new kind of gender you hadn't heard of). This year is an election year for our Federal Government, potentially the world's most boring government, for no other reason than during its entire term, if you asked me who was our Prime Minister I'd actually have to stop and think for a moment. Maybe our 31st PM shou...

TV Series Review: Creature Commandos (2024) No Spoilers

O fficially, Creature Commandos is the first show of James Gunn's kind of reboot of the DCU. Technically though, it starts with James Gunn's, The Suicide Squad , and includes his series, Peacemaker , as the events of both are either referenced or felt within the show. Potentially that means Margot Robbie is Harley Quinn in the DCU, but I'd be surprised if she would even want another crack at it, let alone that James didn't recast the role. However that's a whole other rabbit hole for a character that may not appear again for at least a few more years. Creature Commandos is Suicide Squad but with monsters, and no real threat of Suicide - well, having your head blown off if you stray from the mission at least. Though I don't recall that being a thing in Gunn's Suicide Squad movie since the team was renamed 'Task Force X'? Amanda Waller (Viola Davis) somehow still has a job, but is no longer allowed to use humans on her team, so she assembles a team of...

TET.Life (The Extraordinary Tourist Life)

Search This Blog